Instagram comment services are not judged by price alone. What matters is whether the comments stay on the post, whether they read as something a real account would write, and whether the order affects the rest of the account's activity. The comparison below covers all three.
| Site |
30-Day Comment Drop |
Password Required |
Custom Comments |
| Famety |
2% |
No |
Yes |
| Trollishly |
4% |
No |
Yes |
| BoostFollowers |
5% |
No |
Limited |
| SocialFried |
9% |
No |
Limited |
| BuzzVoice |
11% |
No |
Yes |
| IgComment |
14% |
No |
Yes |
| SocialWick |
19% |
No |
Limited |
| Buzzoid |
21% |
No |
No |
| MediaMister |
22% |
No |
Limited |
| Twicsy |
22% |
No |
No |
| SocialBoosting |
23% |
No |
Limited |
| GetAFollower |
25% |
No |
Limited |
| Poprey |
26% |
No |
Limited |
| Goread |
28% |
No |
No |
| Famoid |
29% |
No |
Limited |
Custom comment availability and package pricing change from provider to provider more often than the core drop-rate pattern, so confirm current options on the order page before comparing final cost.
Each provider was ordered directly, using the same Instagram account and matching order sizes of 25, 50, 100, 250, 500, and 1,000 comments. Comment counts were tracked at day 1, 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, and 30 to measure how many comments remained on the post over time. Alongside that, the account's follower count was tracked over the same 30-day window to see whether a comment order had any measurable effect beyond the post itself. Checkout flow, custom comment options, and support access were reviewed separately from the numbers.
Four things determine whether a comment order is worth the price: whether the comments stay on the post past the first week, whether they read as relevant to the actual content (not generic filler text), whether the checkout process asks for a password, and whether custom comment text is available if generic comments don't fit the post. A provider that's clear about all four is easier to evaluate than one that only advertises comment count.
Famety, based on the lowest 30-day comment drop rate tested (2%) combined with the strongest positive follower rate lift (26%) and a no-password, custom-comment checkout.
Famety and Trollishly both offer custom comment text with multiple variations, rather than pulling from a small generic pool, which matters when comments need to sound specific to the post rather than interchangeable with any other post on the platform.
SocialWick's speed-tier system applies to comments as well as its other services, letting users choose faster delivery at checkout. As with likes and views, delivery speed is only half the picture, cross-check it against a provider's retention data rather than treating speed alone as the deciding factor.
Best Option for Brands and Creators
Famety and Trollishly both combine low comment drop rates with custom text support, which matters for brand accounts where generic comments would look out of place next to product-specific captions.
Best Option for Post Engagement Support
BuzzVoice and IgComment both focus specifically on comments rather than spreading across unrelated services, which keeps their package descriptions and delivery process centered on comment quality rather than treating it as an add-on to a followers order.
Generic, repeated phrases are easy to spot on a post. Check whether a provider's comments vary in wording and length, and whether custom text is an option for posts that need something specific.
Custom comments cost more and take longer to deliver than generic ones, but they're the only way to guarantee the comment text actually references the post. Confirm turnaround time for custom orders separately from the standard delivery window.
Delivery Speed
A stated delivery window on the order page is more useful than a vague estimate, especially for time-sensitive posts. As the retention data above shows, speed and retention don't always move together, so check both.
Drop Rate and Refill Policy
The 30-day comment drop ranged from 2% (Famety) to 29% (Famoid) across the providers tested here, a wide enough gap that it should factor into any comparison alongside price. A stated refill policy matters most for providers in the higher end of that range.
Password Requirement
None of the 15 providers compared in this article request an Instagram password at checkout. Treat this as a baseline requirement for any provider not covered here, not a differentiator.
Customer Support
Confirm that support can be reached through more than a contact form, and that responses address the specific order rather than repeating general information already listed on the site.
Pricing and Package Flexibility
Compare cost per comment across package sizes (25 through 1,000 in this test), and weigh that against the drop rate. A cheaper package with a 29% drop rate can end up costing more per surviving comment than a pricier one with a 2% drop rate.
A comment section gives a post a reason to be read past the caption. Posts with visible discussion tend to hold attention longer than ones with only a like count.
A follower rate that rises alongside a comment order, as seen with Famety (+26%) and Trollishly (+17%) in this test, suggests the comments are landing on a post that's also drawing in new visitors, not just adding text to an otherwise static page.
Relevant comments can prompt real followers to respond, which is where organic engagement actually comes from. Generic or repeated comments are less likely to prompt any reply at all.
A post with comments but no likes or views looks inconsistent. Pairing a comments order with the other engagement metrics covered elsewhere in this comparison keeps the numbers proportional to each other, which is part of what makes the difference between an account that reads as active and one that reads as padded.
Why No Password Delivery Matters
None of the providers reviewed here need account access to deliver comments. A checkout process asking for a password has no legitimate reason to request one and should be treated as a reason to choose a different provider. If cost is the priority, weigh a paid order against a free Instagram service before paying.
Comments that don't relate to the post are easy to identify as purchased, which defeats the purpose of ordering them in the first place. Relevance matters as much as retention when judging whether an order was worth the price.
Providers without a stated delivery window, without custom comment options, and without a clear drop-rate history are harder to evaluate before ordering and, based on the data above, tend to correlate with weaker 30-day retention.
What Users Should Check Before Ordering
Confirm delivery timing, whether custom text is available, the provider's password policy, and its stated (or testable) drop rate before paying. If a site provides none of that information upfront, treat it as a lower-confidence option regardless of price.
Famety, for the widest custom comment support paired with the lowest 30-day drop rate in this comparison.
Best for Fast Delivery
SocialWick, for its speed-tier delivery structure, with the caveat that its 19% drop rate should be weighed against the delivery speed itself.
Best for Creators
Famety and Trollishly, based on low drop rates and package sizes suited to individual accounts rather than only bulk orders.
Best for Brands
Famety, for the combination of custom comment text and the strongest secondary follower rate lift measured in testing.
Best for Agencies
MediaMister, for multi-platform coverage that lets an agency manage comments alongside other services from one provider, or Famety for agencies that want the best retention numbers on Instagram specifically.
Comment retention varied more across these 15 providers than any single price comparison would suggest, ranging from a 2% drop over 30 days at the top of this list to a 29% drop at the bottom. That gap, combined with the secondary shift in follower activity seen alongside it, is a more useful way to judge a comments provider than package price alone. For users who want comments that read as relevant and hold up over time, Famety's combination of low drop rate, custom text support, and positive secondary lift covers the most ground. For users focused specifically on cost or on a particular use case, such as fast delivery or multi-platform coverage, the mid-tier and lower-tier providers on this list remain workable options depending on which trade-off matters most.
